diff --git a/User/UserCrud.cs b/User/UserCrud.cs
index 783c7e0..996d440 100644
--- a/User/UserCrud.cs
+++ b/User/UserCrud.cs
@@ -299,130 +299,50 @@ namespace raven_integration
         }
 
 
+        /// <summary>
+        /// 
+        /// </summary>       
+        [Fact]
+        public async void NonUniqueLoginShouldFail()
+        {
+            var UniqueLogin = Util.Uniquify("NonUniqueLoginShouldFail");
+            //CREATE FIRST USER        
+            dynamic d = new JObject();
+            d.name = Util.Uniquify("NonUniqueLoginShouldFail");
+            d.notes = "notes";
+            d.customFields = Util.UserRequiredCustomFieldsJsonString();
+            d.active = false;
+            d.login = UniqueLogin;
+            d.password = Util.Uniquify("PASSWORD");
+            d.roles = 0;//norole
+            d.userType = 3;//non scheduleable
+
+            ApiResponse a = await Util.PostAsync("User", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), d.ToString());
+            Util.ValidateDataReturnResponseOk(a);
 
 
 
-//This is testing datalist, not user crud, removing
-        // /// <summary>
-        // /// 
-        // /// </summary>
-        // [Fact]
-        // public async void UserListFilterAndSortWorks()
-        // {
+            //Attempt create second with same login
+            d = new JObject();
+            d.name = Util.Uniquify("2NonUniqueLoginShouldFail");
+            d.notes = "notes";
+            d.customFields = Util.UserRequiredCustomFieldsJsonString();
+            d.active = false;
+            d.login = UniqueLogin;
+            d.password = Util.Uniquify("PASSWORD");
+            d.roles = 0;//norole
+            d.userType = 3;//non scheduleable
 
-        //     var ObjectNameStart = Util.Uniquify("UserListFilterAndSortWorks");
+            a = await Util.PostAsync("User", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), d.ToString());
 
-        //     //CREATE 3 TEST OBJECTS TO TEST ORDER
-        //     long FirstInOrdertId = 0;
-        //     long SecondInOrderId = 0;
-        //     long ThirdInOrderId = 0;
+            Util.ValidateErrorCodeResponse(a, 2200, 400);
+            Util.ShouldContainValidationError(a, "Login", "2206");
+            /*
+            "{\"error\":{\"code\":\"2200\",\"details\":[{\"target\":\"Login\",\"error\":\"2206\"}],\"message\":\"Object did not pass validation\"}}"
+            */
 
-        //     dynamic d = new JObject();
-        //     d.name = Util.Uniquify(ObjectNameStart);
-        //     d.active = false;
-        //     d.login = Util.Uniquify("LOGIN");
-        //     d.password = Util.Uniquify("PASSWORD");
-        //     d.roles = 0;//norole
+        }
 
-        //     d.userType = 3;//non scheduleable
-        //     //Required by form custom rules
-        //     d.notes = "notes";
-        //     d.customFields = Util.UserRequiredCustomFieldsJsonString();
-
-        //     ApiResponse a = await Util.PostAsync("User", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), d.ToString());
-        //     Util.ValidateDataReturnResponseOk(a);
-        //     FirstInOrdertId = a.ObjectResponse["data"]["id"].Value<long>();
-
-        //     d = new JObject();
-        //     d.name = Util.Uniquify(ObjectNameStart);
-        //     d.login = Util.Uniquify("LOGIN");
-        //     d.password = Util.Uniquify("PASSWORD");
-        //     d.roles = 0;//norole
-
-        //     d.userType = 3;//non scheduleable
-        //     d.active = true;
-        //     //Required by form custom rules
-        //     d.notes = "notes";
-        //     d.customFields = Util.UserRequiredCustomFieldsJsonString();
-
-        //     a = await Util.PostAsync("User", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), d.ToString());
-        //     Util.ValidateDataReturnResponseOk(a);
-        //     ThirdInOrderId = a.ObjectResponse["data"]["id"].Value<long>();
-
-        //     d = new JObject();
-        //     d.name = Util.Uniquify(ObjectNameStart);
-        //     d.login = Util.Uniquify("LOGIN");
-        //     d.password = Util.Uniquify("PASSWORD");
-        //     d.roles = 0;//norole
-
-        //     d.userType = 3;//non scheduleable
-        //     d.active = false;
-        //     //Required by form custom rules
-        //     d.notes = "notes";
-        //     d.customFields = Util.UserRequiredCustomFieldsJsonString();
-
-        //     a = await Util.PostAsync("User", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), d.ToString());
-        //     Util.ValidateDataReturnResponseOk(a);
-        //     SecondInOrderId = a.ObjectResponse["data"]["id"].Value<long>();
-
-
-        //     //CREATE FILTER
-
-        //     //FILTER IN BY NAME FOR TESTING THIS RUN ONLY
-        //     // dynamic dfilter = new JArray();
-        //     // //name starts with filter to constrict to widgets that this test block created only
-        //     // dynamic DataFilterNameStart = new JObject();
-        //     // DataFilterNameStart.fld = "username";
-        //     // DataFilterNameStart.op = Util.OpStartsWith;
-        //     // DataFilterNameStart.value = ObjectNameStart;
-        //     // dfilter.Add(DataFilterNameStart);
-
-        //     // dynamic dsortarray = new JArray();
-
-        //     //SORT ORDER ###################
-        //     //sort by active then by ID 
-
-        //     // dynamic dsort = new JObject();
-        //     // dsort.fld = "useractive";
-        //     // dsort.dir = "+";
-        //     // dsortarray.Add(dsort);
-
-        //     // dsort = new JObject();
-        //     // dsort.fld = "df";
-        //     // dsort.dir = "+";
-        //     // dsortarray.Add(dsort);
-
-        //     dynamic dListView = new JArray();
-        //     //name starts with filter to constrict to widgets that this test block created only     
-        //     dListView.Add(Util.BuildSimpleFilterDataListViewColumn("username", Util.OpStartsWith, ObjectNameStart));
-        //     dListView.Add(Util.BuildSimpleSortDataListViewColumn("useractive", "+"));
-        //     //DEPRECATED NO DF ANYMORE dListView.Add(Util.BuildSimpleSortDataListViewColumn("df", "+"));
-
-        //     //NOW FETCH WIDGET LIST WITH FILTER UserDataList
-        //     // a = await Util.GetAsync($"DataList/list?DataListKey=UserDataList&Offset=0&Limit=999&DataFilterId={DataFilterId.ToString()}", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"));
-        //     a = await Util.PostAsync($"DataList", await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"), Util.BuildDataListRequestEx(dListView, 999, 0, "TestUserDataList"));
-        //     Util.ValidateDataReturnResponseOk(a);
-        //     Util.ValidateHTTPStatusCode(a, 200);
-
-        //     //assert contains exactly 3 records
-        //     ((JArray)a.ObjectResponse["data"]).Count.Should().Be(3);
-
-        //     //assert the order returned
-        //     a.ObjectResponse["data"][0][0]["i"].Value<long>().Should().Be(FirstInOrdertId);
-        //     a.ObjectResponse["data"][1][0]["i"].Value<long>().Should().Be(SecondInOrderId);
-        //     a.ObjectResponse["data"][2][0]["i"].Value<long>().Should().Be(ThirdInOrderId);
-
-
-        //     a = await Util.DeleteAsync("User/" + FirstInOrdertId.ToString(), await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"));
-        //     Util.ValidateHTTPStatusCode(a, 204);
-
-        //     a = await Util.DeleteAsync("User/" + SecondInOrderId.ToString(), await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"));
-        //     Util.ValidateHTTPStatusCode(a, 204);
-
-        //     a = await Util.DeleteAsync("User/" + ThirdInOrderId.ToString(), await Util.GetTokenAsync("manager", "l3tm3in"));
-        //     Util.ValidateHTTPStatusCode(a, 204);
-
-        // }
 
 
         //==================================================